MS Gets Bearish


Morgan Stanley has warned that current jitters on the global credit markets could spread to equity markets. Stock market corrections - after an increase in the cost of debt - historically follow six months later, suggesting that the current rally on Wall Street and European bourses may be more fragile than it looks.
(the key words are "could spread", I love how non-committal highly paid people are remunerated to say wishy-washy stuff)


The current rally on Wall Street and European bourses may be more fragile than it looks. A rise in the interest rate spread between risky debt and benchmark treasuries knocks away a key support for share prices by raising the cost of money for leveraged buyouts, but there is often a long delay before investors react. A study by MS found that credit spreads began to widen on average six months before every stock market correction of 10pc or more over the past 20 years. The current widening began in February, picking up speed over the past three weeks. If history is any guide, this could point to a global stock market slide as soon as August. Morgan Stanley's model suggests a 14pc fall, or 2,000 points off the Dow.
(that's the most important line of thought from the entire document, credit spreads widen for 6 months on average before actually collapse of equity markets)

"This is not the first time that equity markets take their time to react to bad news," said the bank's chief Europe strategist, Teun Draaisma. "The fundamentals have deteriorated. Equities have reached all-time highs despite higher rates, wider spreads, higher oil, Chinese tightening, and a stronger euro. There is a widespread belief in continuation of good global growth without inflation. While we are not expecting a recession for another two to three years, we believe chances are high that this belief will be seriously tested soon."

Mr Draaisma added that ever clearer signs of "stagflation" would soon start weighing on confidence. The current pattern looks similar to the relentless rise in spreads from February to September 2000 when the stock markets finally tipped over. Mr Draaisma said the iTraxx Crossover index measuring risk appetite for high-yield bonds touched bottom at around 170 in February. It has since jumped to 320 - mostly this month - implying at 150 basis point rise in the cost of raising capital.

Morgan Stanley said the trigger for a stock market fall could be a sudden unwinding of yen "carry trade" from Japan, a major source of global liquidity. The Bank of Japan in expected to raise rates a quarter point to 0.75pc in August. The worst stock market falls have been -58.4pc after the dotcom bust, -34.3pc in October 1987 and -30.8pc in a two-month shake-out after Russia defaulted in 1998, as measured on the MSCI Europe index. Morgan Stanley said its "value indicator" shows that the median stock in Europe is now selling at a record high price-to-earnings ratio of near 20. This measure includes smaller and mid-size companies. The price/earnings ratios on big blue-chip companies are much lower, hence the widespread belief that stocks are "cheap". Mr Draaisma's study found that worst performing stocks at times of widening spreads are financial and industrial groups. Among the worst losers in previous bouts have been Man Group (-39pc), Swedbank (-38pc) and Barclays (-35pc). The best defensive stocks have been consumer staples such as Carrefour (+41pc), Unilever (+41pc) and Nestle (+39pc).

(the big corrections over the past 20 years: dotcom - excessive run up in a single sector, not evident in present times; October 87 interest rate jumps and dollar decline - dollar is declining but it actually boosted purchases of US equity in return; Russia default in 98 - risk of default by an emerging market has reduced sharply over the past 3-5 years ... as for widening credit spreads, it does not hit corporations that badly as listed corporates are at an all time high holding cash balances, it may affect the leveraged buyout companies, so we will have smaller deals that are less leveraged, not an entirely bad thing ... end conclusion - good reading material but MS is probably wrong).

Comments

doraiddd said…
"....good reading material but MS is probably wrong."


Dali,
if only you were as well remunerated as Mr Draaisma, I would say that your final statement lacks the force of previous conviction (especially coming on the back of MFCB and AZRB buys...)

I believe what MS cant say is that from their recent observations of earth's tidal flow, earth is starting to align with ALL the moons within our planetary system (including all of jupiter's moons) which in turn is starting to align with the sun and other distant dead imploded stars, and as such, IT CANT BE GOOD....

But seriously, even the ultra-conservative seers and sages that I consult in the old Jap houses have repeatedly but quietly and firmly told me to exit equities by August (and swap to bonds and GOLD??).

But not before 19000 on the nikkei and 1400 and 2.5 bil hre on Bursa, I insisted... The latter I believe will be fulfilled this week and its then sayonara KLSE from me...

And no, this is not inspired from Matthias' 'financial tsunami' on malaysia-today either... (Boy, wat poor delivery that guy has...)

Btw, wat happened to KJ's mugshot and short stories here?

SCARED-AHH?? 'cos i sure am....
Salvatore_Dali said…
doraidd,

there is no need to tempt fate ... you want to be angry, you want people to be aware, but you also want to survive, I cannot tell you how many told me to take the thing down within just 24 hours ... billy, don't be a hero
cin said…
Ha ha! The Chinese has a saying "Of the 36 strategies, to run is the best." Run, if you need to - it doesn't mean that you are a coward.
doraiddd said…
Billy dont be a hero...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qDq_xJlF0TE

enjoy! Muahahahahah....
mkts are already reacting.....but then again its seems to me there is a big correction happenning every month somewhere somehow...would i be wrong to assume that nowadays mkts are re-correcting on a adhoc basis (monthly) or perhaps there is so much liquidity in the system that managers and players are just dont where else to put the funds into...either way in these new unchartered waters one would say "its a whole new ball game".